In airplane cabins, the debate over reclining seats has become a controversial topic among passengers. The question of whether it’s rude to recline your seat mid-flight delves into the realms of personal space, common courtesy, and the battle for comfort in the skies.
Samira Hammadi, Etiquette Expert, Pilot and aviation service veteran said in an exclusive interview with Arabian Business that she believes it is generally not considered impolite to recline seats, airplane seats are engineered to recline, and passengers have the right to adjust them for added comfort during a flight. However, “it is crucial to exercise courtesy and awareness of safety measures.”
She suggests that passengers should refrain from reclining seats during take-off, landing, meal services, turbulence or when the seatbelt sign is illuminated.
If one does choose to recline, the way to do so might be through, “Communication with the passenger behind, slow and considerate reclining, and limiting the use of recline during resting periods are additional etiquette to uphold, especially in economy class where personal space is limited.”
Another key factor that plays in the perception of this debate is cultural differences, Hammadi believes that the way to combat varying norms of personal space, communication, styles and attitudes is if “airlines can contribute by considering diverse cultural expectations in their policies, fostering a more inclusive and considerate atmosphere.”
Airlines role and potential changes
An airline can play a “pivotal role” in managing tensions arising from the debate of reclining seats. Hammadi suggests “in-flight etiquette guidelines, flexible seating options and passenger feedback mechanisms.”
When is it acceptable to recline seats?
Despite passengers being divided into pro-recline and non-recline, there exists a possibility of reclining during “acceptable times.”
Long-haul flights and after-meal services are generally considered an appropriate time to recline seats while the less acceptable times are during meal service, take-off, landing and turbulence.
Hammadi offers advice for those passengers struggling with the debate on both sides of the spectrum:
For reclining passengers:
- Be mindful of timing: Recline your seat during appropriate times, such as on long-haul flights or after meal services. Avoid reclining during take-off, landing, meal service, turbulence, or when the seatbelt sign is illuminated.
- Check with the passenger behind: A quick, polite check with the passenger behind you can go a long way. Non-verbal cues or a brief verbal exchange can help gauge their comfort level and prevent potential discomfort.
- Recline slowly and gradually: To minimise disruption for the passenger behind, recline your seat slowly and gradually. This allows them to adjust to the change without feeling abruptly encroached upon.
- Consideration for personal space: Be aware that not everyone may share the same comfort level with reduced personal space. Exercise empathy and be willing to compromise, especially on shorter flights where reclining might be less essential.
For anti-reclining passengers:
- Express concerns politely: If you’re uncomfortable with a reclined seat, express your concerns politely and calmly. Most passengers are willing to accommodate if they understand your perspective. Communication is key.
- Before utilising knee defenders: Devices designed to limit the recline of the seat in front of you – it’s crucial to check the specific regulations set by the airline. Adhere to the company’s policies and seek approval from the onboard crew, always keeping in mind the comfort of both yourself and fellow passengers, following proper etiquette.
- Adapt to the situation: Recognise that reclining is a standard feature on most flights. If the seat in front reclines, try adjusting your own posture or using amenities provided, like neck pillows or seat cushions, to enhance your comfort without escalating tension.
- Choose your battles: While advocating for your comfort, it’s also crucial to pick your battles. On shorter flights or when reclining is minimal, consider whether it’s worth addressing the issue or adapting to the situation for the duration of the journey.
The unwritten etiquette of air travel remains at the center of the controversy, with opinions sharply divided. “Remember that everyone is navigating the challenges of confined space,” she concluded.
Follow us on
